All posts
How to

How to pitch the websites AI already quotes (without being spammy)

To pitch the websites AI already quotes, start with the pages AI cites when shoppers ask about products like yours. Read the page and find the person who wrote it. Then send one short, honest email that explains why your product fits their readers. Follow up once, then stop. Never pay for a spot or swap links.

This works because AI assistants build their answers from pages they trust. If a trusted roundup names your rivals and not you, getting a fair mention there is one of the most direct ways to show up in the answer. Here is how to do it, one step at a time.

Step 1: Find the pages AI already quotes for your products

Open ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini in a fresh chat. Ask the questions your shoppers ask right before they buy, like "best unscented beard oil for sensitive skin" or "best gift for a new gardener under $50". Note every page each answer links to as a source.

Do this for 10 to 20 questions. After a while the same sites keep coming back. Those repeat sites are your list. Look hardest at "best X" roundups and gift guides that name your rivals but not you. Those are your best openings.

Each assistant leans on different sites, so check all of them. A page ChatGPT loves may never show up in Google's AI answer at the top of the results. Favour pages that were updated recently, because writers who refresh a list are more likely to add to it.

  • Use long, specific questions, not one-word searches
  • Save the question, the page link and the brands it names
  • Mark pages that name rivals but not you
  • Check the date the page was last updated

Step 2: Read the page properly before you write

Read the whole roundup, not just the headline. Work out how the writer picks products. Do they care about price, materials, made in Australia, or who the product suits? Look at what they said about each product they chose.

Then ask yourself an honest question: does my product really belong here? If the list is "best budget kettles" and yours costs three times more, skip it. A pitch that does not fit wastes the writer's time and makes your brand look careless.

Write down one or two details from the page you can mention. This shows you actually read it. Writers get many lazy emails that clearly came from a template, and a real detail stands out.

Step 3: Find the person who wrote it

Look for the writer's name near the top or bottom of the page. Many sites link the name to a short profile. That profile often lists an email address or a social account.

If there is no name, check the site's contact or "write for us" page. For a big publisher, look for an editor who covers your kind of product. LinkedIn can help you confirm the person still works there.

Send each email to one real person. Do not guess a dozen addresses or blast the same note to a whole newsroom. That feels like spam, and it often gets treated as spam.

Step 4: Write a short, honest email

Keep it under about 150 words. Say who you are, name the exact page, and explain in plain terms why your product fits their readers. Give real facts: price, size, what it is made of, who it suits. Be upfront about any limits.

Make it easy to say yes. Offer a sample if it makes sense for your product. Link to the product page. Do not ask for a link, a rating or a top spot. Just ask them to consider your product next time they update the page.

Tools can help you draft this. FirstPicked's Sites AI trusts tab shows the pages AI uses for your buying questions and can find the writer and draft a pitch for you to edit and send.

  • Subject: An idea for your best gift guides for gardeners
  • Hi Sam, I run Leafy Co, a small Australian brand. I read your gardening gifts list and liked that you picked tools that last.
  • Our pruning snips are $45, made with a steel blade and suit small hands. They might fit readers who want a gift under $50.
  • Happy to send a pair to try. No pressure either way. Thanks, Jo

Step 5: Follow up once, then let it go

Writers are busy and emails get buried. If you hear nothing after about a week, send one short, polite follow-up. Reply in the same email thread so they can see your first note.

Keep it to two or three lines. Something like: "Just checking this reached you. Happy to send a sample if it helps." Do not add pressure or new demands.

If there is still no reply, stop. No answer is an answer. Chasing someone three or four times can damage your name with that writer for good. Move on to the next page on your list, and check back on the roundup when it is next updated.

Step 6: Never buy links, swap links or fake reviews

Some sites will offer to add you for a fee. Others suggest a link swap. Paying for links, swapping links and writing fake reviews are against the platforms' rules. They can hurt how a store's pages show in search, and they put your brand's trust at risk.

You also cannot buy your way into ChatGPT's answer. ChatGPT now shows ads on some plans, but OpenAI's help page says ads appear below the answer, are clearly labelled, and that advertisers have no ability to shape, rank or change ChatGPT's responses. Google is different: Google Ads Help says ads can show above, below or within AI Overviews in Australia and other countries. Those ad slots are paid and marked, and they are separate from the sites the answer itself cites.

The fair mention inside the answer has to be earned. The SteelSeries case study published by The Drum in June 2026 is one example of this approach. The team found the few review sites and Reddit threads AI trusted in its category and focused there, adding useful posts rather than brand promotion.

Key takeaways

  • Start with the exact pages ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini cite for your shoppers' buying questions.
  • Only pitch roundups your product genuinely fits, and show you read the page.
  • Send one short, honest email to one real writer, with real facts about your product.
  • Follow up once after about a week, then move on.
  • Never pay for a spot, swap links or post fake reviews, because they break the platforms' rules and hurt your store.

Questions people ask

How many websites should I pitch each week?

Quality beats volume. Three to five well-fitted pitches a week is easier to do well than 50 rushed ones. Each pitch should mention the page and explain why your product fits. A handful of good emails tends to get more replies than a mass send.

Should I offer the writer money or a discount code?

No. Paying for a mention or a link is against the platforms' rules and can put your store at risk. Offering a sample to try is fine when it suits your product. Let the writer decide freely whether to include you.

How long until a new mention shows up in AI answers?

There is no fixed time. AI answers change week to week, and new mentions can take weeks to months to show up. Keep checking the same buying questions and watch the trend, not one day.

Can I pay to appear in ChatGPT's answer?

No. OpenAI's help page says ChatGPT's ads sit below the answer, are labelled, and that advertisers cannot shape or rank its responses. The mention inside the answer is earned from what AI reads about you on trusted sites.

What if the writer says no?

Thank them and leave it there. A polite reply keeps the door open for the next time they update the list. Then move on to the next page on your list.

Sources

Every number in this article comes from one of these pages. Written by the FirstPicked team with help from AI, and checked against our facts sheet and these sources before publishing. Nothing here is a promise of results.

Want to see if ChatGPT recommends your products? Try our free AI Visibility Checker.